HM Amit Shah defamation case: Complainant to challenge Rahul Gandhi’s acquittal

Posted on by Vividh Bharathi

Sultanpur, Oct 26 (IANS) The complainant in the defamation case related to Union Home Minister Amit Shah said he would challenge the Monday verdict of a special MP-MLA court in UP’s Sultanpur acquitting Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi.

After the court acquitted Gandhi in the case registered under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), complainant Vijay Mishra said he would challenge the decision before an appellate court after obtaining a certified copy of the order and seeking legal advice.

Santosh Pandey, counsel for the complainant, said the court did not consider Mishra an aggrieved person in the case and also did not find Gandhi’s remark to be defamatory.

Gandhi reached the special MP-MLA court in Sultanpur at around 11.10 a.m. on Monday. Security arrangements were tightened on the court premises ahead of the verdict, and the courtroom door was closed after Gandhi entered.

Earlier, Congress workers had gathered near Kurebhar on the Purvanchal Expressway to welcome him.

According to Pandey, the court considered three key aspects while delivering its verdict. He said the court accepted the CD submitted by the complainant as proven evidence but did not recognise Mishra as an aggrieved person in the matter. It also did not find Gandhi’s statement to be defamatory and acquitted him of the charges.

Pandey said the complainant’s side had not yet received a certified copy of the judgment. Once the order becomes available, it will be examined legally before a decision is taken on the next course of action.

Mishra also said he would study the judgment through his lawyer after obtaining a certified copy and subsequently approach an appellate court after consulting legal experts.

He added that he had been pursuing the case continuously since filing it in 2018.

The case relates to an alleged remark made by Gandhi during a press conference in Bengaluru in May 2018, during campaigning for the Karnataka Assembly elections. At the time, HM Shah was the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) President.

Mishra alleged that Gandhi had used the word “murderer” while referring to Shah during the press conference, thereby damaging the reputation of the BJP and its workers.

At the time, Mishra was a BJP district Vice-President and Chairman of the Sultanpur District Cooperative Bank. He filed a defamation complaint against Gandhi on August 4, 2018, citing a CD of the alleged statement as evidence.

The proceedings initially began before a civil court before the case was transferred to the special MP-MLA court, which deals with cases involving Members of Parliament and Members of Legislative Assemblies.

The court issued a summons to Gandhi on November 27, 2023. He appeared before it on February 20, 2024, and was granted bail against two personal bonds of Rs 25,000 each. Gandhi had denied the allegations at the time.

During the trial, the complainant’s side recorded the statements of Mishra, Anil Mishra, and Ramchand Dubey. Mishra also sought permission to obtain Gandhi’s voice sample and compare it with the recording on the CD. However, the trial court rejected the request.

–IANS

rs/vd

Related Posts

Pawan Khera: Rahul Gandhi was threatened over BJP’s larger ‘anti-farmer’ agenda, not just 2020 laws

New Delhi, Aug 2 (IANS) As the ruling BJP and the Congress on Saturday locked horns over Rahul Gandhi’s claim of receiving threats from Late Union minister Arun Jaitley over the farm laws, the grand old party claimed that the episode was a failed bid to silence their leader on his pro-farmer agenda.

While Jaitley’s son strongly rebutted Gandhi’s claims, the Congress put its weight behind the Leader of Opposition, claiming that the controversial threat aimed at silencing him was made at the behest of top BJP leaders.

Pawan Khera, Chairman, Media and Publicity Department, AICC, said in a post on X, “What matters is not who conveyed the threat but on whose behalf was it being conveyed. The hand behind it was the Modi-Shah duo.”

Khera said, “The intention of the threats was to silence us but they have only ever strengthened our resolve.”

“This was never about one Bill or one Act – it was about crushing Rahul Gandhi’s fierce, unyielding defence of India’s farmers or the Indian people in general,” wrote Khera on X.

The political storm on Saturday erupted after Gandhi said at the party’s Annual Legal Conclave 2025 that Arun Jaitley had threatened him with action if he carried on the protest against the three farm laws.

Hours later, Rohan Jaitley expressed shock and disappointment over Gandhi’s remarks and said, “The farm laws that Rahul Gandhi is referring to were passed in 2020, more than a year after my father’s demise in August 2019. My father had been unwell for several months before his death. So, the question of him threatening anyone on this issue simply does not arise.”

A little later, Khera took to social media and countered Rohan Jaitley by presenting the chain of events that led to the threatening episode mentioned by Gandhi.

Khera said, “The Farm Laws of 2020 were not the only anti-farmer legislations of the BJP government. They were the culmination of a long, deliberate, anti-farmer agenda that the BJP government had been cooking up in its cauldron of destructive policy.”

“The first blow came in December 2014 itself, when Modi resorted to diluting the Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation Bill of 2013. Then in 2017 came the so‑called Model Agricultural Produce and Livestock Marketing Act – another backdoor assault on farmers’ rights,” he said.

The chief of AICC Media and Publicity Department said, “The Congress, led by Rahul Gandhi, vehemently opposed these anti-farmer laws. It is in this context that the late Arun Jaitley came to 10 Janpath to meet Rahul Gandhi carrying a threat. But he forgot that Rahul Ji is a Gandhi, not a Savarkar.”

–IANS

rch/dan

Hyderabad Police raid houses of history-sheeters, seize knives

Hyderabad, Dec 24 (IANS) Police in Hyderabad raided the houses of notorious history-sheeter Zafar Pahelwan and his sons in connection with the recent murder of a businessman and booked cases against them under the Arms Act following the recovery of knives.

Police said the raids were conducted early Wednesday morning as part of intensified action against rowdyism and criminal elements.

The raids were conducted on the houses of Zaffar Pahelwan, a rowdy sheeter involved in 40 criminal cases, Sayeed Pahelwan, a former rowdy sheeter involved in five criminal cases and Sulemaan Pahelwan, who is involved in one criminal case.

A total of 60 police personnel participated in the raid, during which multiple illegal knives and documents related to suspected illegal properties. The seized documents are currently under detailed verification, said Deputy Commissioner of Police (South Zone) Kiran Khare.

Based on the recovery of illegal weapons, police registered two FIRs under the Arms Act against the three accused.

The DCP said all the accused are absconding. Special police teams have been formed and deployed to trace and apprehend them at the earliest.

Police have appealed to the public to come forward and share any information related to the accused or their activities. It has been assured that the identity of informants will be kept strictly confidential.

Police further stated that rowdyism and criminal activities will not be tolerated, and stringent action will be taken against those involved in such offences to maintain law and order.

Junaid Bin Mohammad Bharmoos was murdered by a group led by three rowdy sheeters in full public view at Chotapool, Yakutpura, on December 3, when he prevented them from extorting money from people.

A total of 12 accused were named in the murder case. While six accused were later arrested by police, six others are absconding.

The arrested persons are Omer Bin Hamza Al Jabri (35), a rowdy sheeter and son of notorious rowdy sheeter Hamza Bin Omer alias Zaffar Pahelwan, Ali Bin Hamza Al Jabri (31), Faisal Bin Habeeb Mohammed (23), Mohammad Maqsood Ali (28), Syed Asghar Ali (20) and Mohammed Taher (25).

Six others, Syed Raheem Ghori Shazib of Rein Bazaar police station, Malik Bin Javid, Azhar, Zubair, Riyan, and Kulsum, are absconding.

According to police, Omer and Ali were demanding money from a person, Farooq, who is a friend of Junaid, when they came to know that he had sold a property.

Junaid intervened when Omer and Ali tried to collect commission from Farooq. He had also done this on previous instances. Keeping it in mind, Omer and Ali, along with their associates, conspired and attacked Junaid, leading to his death.

–IANS

ms/svn

HM Shah, JP Nadda, others pay tributes to Arun Jaitley on his birth anniversary

New Delhi, Dec 28 (IANS) Prominent political leaders from across the country paid heartfelt tributes to the late former Union Minister Arun Jaitley on his birth anniversary, celebrating his enduring contributions to the nation.

Union Home Minister Amit Shah remembered Jaitley as a key figure in shaping India’s policies.

“Remembering Arun Jaitley Ji on his Jayanti. As an expert in legal and policy matters, Arun Jaitley Ji contributed to the seamless implementation of the government’s vision, and as an orator par excellence, he successfully communicated it to the masses both inside and outside the Parliament. His legacy will continue to inspire new-age policymakers for good,” HM Shah wrote in a post on X on Saturday.

BJP President and Union Minister J.P. Nadda also shared his tribute. “I remember and pay my respects to senior BJP leader, former Finance Minister of the country, and Padma Vibhushan Shri Arun Jaitley Ji on his birth anniversary. Your strategic acumen, simplicity, and rational approach impressed all. The work you did in nation-building is unforgettable,” Nadda posted on X.

Minister of Parliamentary Affairs Kiren Rijiju expressed his admiration for Jaitley’s intellect and influence.

“Today, I remember Arun Jaitley Ji on his Jayanti — a leader whose grace, intellect, and commitment set benchmarks for public life. His ability to simplify complexities and connect with people left a profound impact. His contributions and wisdom remain a guiding light for us all,” Rijiju wrote on X.

Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath also paid tribute, emphasising Jaitley’s role in strengthening India.

“Humble tribute to former Union Finance Minister, Padma Vibhushan Arun Jaitley Ji, on his birth anniversary. His contributions to building a ‘Self-reliant India – Strong India’ are unforgettable and inspiring,” he said.

Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma remembered Jaitley for his sharp legal acumen and policy reforms. “Remembering former Finance Minister and one of the tallest leaders of our party, Shraddheya Arun Jaitley Ji, on his Jayanti. Through his sharp legal acumen and brilliant oratory skills, he enriched parliamentary procedures and executed key reforms like GST,” Sarma noted.

Former Union Minister Anurag Thakur also paid homage. “Humble greetings on the birth anniversary of senior BJP leader, former Finance Minister, and Padma Vibhushan awardee Shri Arun Jaitley Ji. His wisdom, understanding, and policy decisions significantly contributed to nation-building. His public life — marked by restraint, simplicity, and ideal thoughts — will always guide us,” Thakur wrote.

Arun Jaitley, a respected figure in Indian politics, continues to inspire leaders across the political spectrum for his contributions to governance, legal reforms, and nation-building.

Jaitley became Finance Minister of India in 2014 when the BJP-led government, under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, came to power. He played a crucial role in shaping economic policies and implementing key economic reforms during his tenure.

He was also known for his articulate communication skills and played a pivotal role in explaining the government’s policies. He passed away in August 2019 after a brief illness.

–IANS

skp/rad