SC disapproves of bail order to send accused to jail upon submission of charge sheet

Posted on by Vividh Bharathi

New Delhi, March 20 (IANS) The Supreme Court has modified a part of an anticipatory bail order of the Patna High Court requiring the trial court to take all “coercive steps to ensure that petitioner (accused) is behind bars” upon submission of the charge sheet.

A bench of Justices Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Prashant Kumar Mishra said that the Patna HC, after giving pre-arrest bail because, at that point of time, nothing serious had come against the petitioner-accused, should then have left it open for the trial court to take a call on submission of the charge sheet.

“The learned counsel for the petitioner is correct that there could not have been a specific direction that upon submission of the charge sheet, the (trial) court shall take all coercive steps to ensure that the petitioner is behind bars. The (Patna HC) Court could have just left it open for the trial court to consider the matter upon the petitioner appearing and then taking a call without there being any mandamus issued to take him into custody,” the Justice Amanullah-led Bench said.

In its impugned direction passed in August last year, the Patna HC had said that “if charge sheet is submitted against the petitioner connecting him with the offence, in that event, the present anticipatory bail order shall lose its effect and the learned trial court shall take all coercive steps to ensure that petitioner is behind bars”.

In the apex court, the petitioner’s counsel contended that such a condition of the accused being taken into custody upon submission of the charge sheet was not proper.

Without interfering with the anticipatory bail order “substantially”, the apex court modified the impugned condition. “We modify the direction given in the last paragraph which shall read that since the charge sheet has now been submitted against the petitioner, he is required to appear before the Court on the question of bail in accordance with law based on the materials before the Court without being prejudiced by the order impugned,” ordered the Justice Amanullah-led Bench.

Further, it asked the petitioner to appear before the court concerned within a period of three weeks and till then, extended the interim protection granted at an earlier occasion.

–IANS

pds/vd

Related Posts

Chetna remains trapped in borewell even after 96 hours, rescue efforts hindered by rain

Jaipur, Dec 27 (IANS) Despite all rescue efforts, Chetna, a 3-year-old girl, remains trapped in a borewell in Kotputli at a depth of 120 feet for 96 hours without food or water. Efforts to rescue her have stretched into the fifth day, with heavy rain and logistical challenges hindering progress.

A parallel pit approximately 170 feet deep has been dug using a piling machine. As of 9:30 a.m., a 162-foot-long pipe has been installed in the pit, with plans to add an additional 8-foot section.

Once complete, “rat miners” are set to descend through the pipe to dig a 20-foot horizontal tunnel connecting the pit to the borewell.

The operation has faced repeated setbacks due to rain and the presence of stone layers obstructing the excavation, said Kotputli-Baharod district collector Kalpana Aggarwal who acknowledged these difficulties, noting that the unpredictable conditions have complicated rescue efforts.

Chetna fell into a 700-foot borewell on Monday. Initial attempts to rescue her using improvised tools succeeded in raising her by 30 feet but failed to extract her completely.

For the past three days, she has remained at 120 feet, showing no signs of movement, while officials remain silent about her condition.

Efforts to rescue her with modern equipment began on December 24 after earlier methods proved ineffective.

However, progress has been slow, and the family has expressed frustration with delays and alleged negligence by authorities.

Meanwhile, Chetna’s mother has fallen unconscious due to stress, and other family members are in distress.

Meanwhile, the rescue teams said that they hope the operation will conclude successfully soon, despite challenges.

Just two weeks ago, a five-year-old boy fell into a borewell in Dausa district of Rajasthan and the rescue operation lasted over 55 hours. However, the boy had lost the battle for life by that time he was taken out.

–IANS

arc/skp

Nagaland 5th northeastern state where women outnumber men in electoral rolls

Kohima, Jan 11 (IANS) Nagaland has become the fifth northeastern state after Manipur, Mizoram, Meghalaya, and Arunachal Pradesh where women voters outnumber men in the electoral rolls and the gender ratio is much higher than the national average, officials said here on Saturday.

A senior election official said that 6,72,395 women general voters outnumbered 6,65,489 male voters in Nagaland’s final electoral rolls, published on Friday after a special summary revision of the photo electoral rolls with January 1, 2025, as the qualifying date.

The official said with the inclusion of 7,310 service voters (7,196 male and 114 female), the total number of voters in the northeastern state increased to 13,45,197, including three third-gender voters.

Against the national gender ratio of 948, the gender ratio in the electoral rolls of Nagaland is 1,010, the official said.

Compared to the draft electoral rolls, published on October 29 last year, 13,642 voters (1.02 per cent increase) were added to the final rolls.

Women voters also outnumber men in the electoral rolls of Manipur, Mizoram, Meghalaya, and Arunachal Pradesh.

The gender ratio in the electoral rolls of Manipur is 1,070, followed by 1,066 in Mizoram, 1,037 in Arunachal Pradesh, and 1,028 in Meghalaya.

In Christian-dominated Nagaland, men controlled all aspects of the society including governance. However, in the last Assembly elections, held on February 27, 2023, for the first time in Nagaland’s electoral history, two women — Salhoutuonuo Kruse (Western Angami) and Hekani Jakhalu (Dimapur-III), were elected to the 60-member house.

Both the winning women candidates belong to the ruling Nationalist Democratic Progressive Party (NDPP), which dominates the United Democratic Alliance (UDA) government in the opposition-less Assembly. With 12 members, the Bharatiya Janata Party is one of the constituents of the UDA government headed by Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio.

–IANS

sc/vd

Odisha LoP Naveen Patnaik writes to Chhattisgarh CM over detention of PRI members

Bhubaneswar, Jan 10 (IANS) Odisha Leader of Opposition Naveen Patnaik on Friday wrote to Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Vishnu Deo Sai, urging the release of Panchayati Raj Institution (PRI) representatives from Kirmira block, Jharsuguda district, who were allegedly detained by the local police in Sareipali, Mahasamund district, Chhattisgarh.

In his letter, Patnaik expressed concern, stating: “I am writing to bring to your attention a disturbing incident where PRI representatives, including Sarpanches and Panchayat Samiti Members from Kirmira block in Jharsuguda district, were detained by Chhattisgarh police at Sareipali police station in Mahasamund district.”

Patnaik noted that the detained leaders were scheduled to participate in a no-confidence motion against the Kirmira block chairperson at 10:30 a.m. on Friday. However, they were reportedly held since midnight, along with Vishal Das, son of former Odisha cabinet Minister Naba Das.

Patnaik urged the Chhattisgarh CM to ensure their immediate release and guarantee their safety during their return to Odisha. He emphasized that many of those detained are women PRI members, underlining the gravity of the situation.

A copy of the letter was also sent to Odisha Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi, requesting necessary action to safeguard the detained PRI representatives.

Meanwhile, former Jharsuguda MLA Dipali Das, sister of Vishal Das, staged a demonstration at the district collector’s office in Jharsuguda on Friday.

Supported by BJD workers, she protested the cancellation of the no-confidence motion against Kirmira block chairperson Bishnupriya Sahoo and the “illegal detention” of her brother and PRI members.

Dipali accused the BJP-led Chhattisgarh government of engaging in “dirty politics” and called the detention an “assault on democracy.”

She alleged that the Chhattisgarh police acted without warrants or evidence, labeling the incident as a violation of legal and democratic principles.

Vishal Das also appealed to the Odisha government and the state police to ensure the safety of those detained, asserting that the detention was illegal.

–IANS

gyan/skp